What would help you make an informed decision about the Commons Upgrade runoff votes?
📢 Help us design the best voter pamphlets
These are some points shared in the last Soft Gov call:
-
How will this proposal affect the TEC in the future
-
Should subjective opinions from community members be shared in the pamphlets?
-
Have one pamphlet that is very objective and one that has opinions from the community
-
Pick top 5 key params to compare between proposals
-
Ask objective questions to the proponents and have a page with their answer.
-
Concise with pros and cons of each proposal
-
Separate params on different spectrums for example: Very inclusive to new members x hatchers can hold voting power for longer – and connect proposals to the respective one.
-
Consider each proposal on worst case scenarios.
-
The target audience might be outside of the people who voted now - how can we simplify a layer further?
Other points to consider
Token Freeze - Token Thaw and Total Vesting Period
- What is the ratio between the freeze and the thaw?
- Is this incentivizing long term sustainability?
Opening Price
- Should the psychological effect of the token affect the opening price? What are other important factors?
- How does the opening price affect hatchers considering the total vesting period?
- How does the opening price affect new token holders?
Common Pool fund
- How does this amount advance token engineering?
- Does it impact voter behavior?
Conviction Voting
- How many proposals will be completed before the total vesting period ends?
- How much subjective value do we need from proposals to secure the economy?
Freeze versus conviction growth
- Shorter curves have a higher minimum conviction
- Longer curves need a lower minimum conviction
- Will everyone in the community have a chance to participate in votes? What is a comfortable min time for proposals to pass?
- What is the largest proposal that could pass?
- If x% of voters are active, what can they pass?
Entry - Exit Tribute
- High entry tribute - low exit tribute implies active governance
- High exit tribute implies more money in the common pool but might not have active governance
- Entry tribute is a market regulator, how will entry, exit tributes likely change over time?
Reserve Ratio
- How gradually do we want the governance decentralization to happen?
- Volatility generates funds x higher reserve ratio is more fair for people coming in late.
Quorum
- If there is a low reserve ratio, the quorum should be higher
- Consider our current token distribution - how many people can pass a proposal?
Delegated Voting
- The more serious we take the delegation, the higher the quorum can be